The Arnie situation - one thread to rule them all...

191012141520

Comments

  • It needs to be sorted though because the Chinese window closes 28 Feb. I can see their meeting our valuation after our window closes and we are left high and dry although Pelle mthink we’d be ok but he has said before that we need another striker in the window however that may be because he knew what was brewing.
  • Did he say we need another striker?

    I missed that.

    Can you point me to where you saw it, thorn?
  • edited January 2019
    We'll I trust the manager and if he says he isn't I the right frame of mind then his head is elsewhere and wants to go imo.
  • Thorn lol

    Also not sure where I read it, but sorry to hear about your family member? Been through similar in the last 12-18 months, stay strong.

    Pellegrini has now said that from what he saw in training last week both Perez and Arnie were not as good as the rest, hence they didn’t make the 18, on top of that there were discussions between MP and MA and he didn’t think he was in the right place.

    I’m sorry but the geezer is an absolute disgrace, I don’t care what his reasons are, the way him and his brother - who is employed / hired by arnie have acted is nothing short of disgusting.

    Redknapp (I know!!) also said yesterday that he was told Arnie refused to travel.

    ;angry
  • My wife asked me this morning to clean out the fire and lay a new one. I said "sorry darling my head's not in the right place this morning." She said that if I want it still on my shoulders I'll get on with it. ;fishslap
  • Mrs G I think it may have been in response to a question at one of his press conferences but can’t remember which.
  • "A manager must choose the players that work better during the week," said Pellegrini. "Marko has his head on another issue so it wasn't a good idea for him to play."
    I trust the manager, last week Pellegrini thought Arnie was in the right frame of mind to play despite him wanting to move to China, this weekend he felt weekend Arnie wasn't in the right frame of mind.

    Now that it seems the deal has fallen through next weekend Pellegrini could decide Arnie is in the right frame again.
  • edited January 2019
    Im actually suprised on here how many are sympathetic to Arnie...
    Why is he being given this im not sure, I trust our managers judgement and at the moment it imo shouldn't be questioned.
    I agree, the club should demand a figure and if not met, he stays, whether he likes it or not, if he doesn't wanna train or play, take him to the cleaners....
    If he should stay, surely it'll be in everyones best interest, including himself to perform, which might then help him get his desired Chinese move at the end of season...or when the transfer market opens again....
  • He trained all week and from what Pellegrini says he decided to leave Arnie out of the squad(unless Pellegrini is lying)

    Noble says none of the players have any problem with Arnie, they want him to stay but they understand why he'd want to move (perhaps because they'd all do the same if they were offered that sort of money).

    For the players football is not personal, its business.

    Can anyone on here honestly say they wouldn't be tempted by four times the money to do the same job somewhere else?
  • If the Chinese deal has fallen through, it would be a tough job for the manger to reintegrate Arnie in the team, especially as the player's heart is not at the Club. I am sure that many fans, like me, would have less affection for him. Club pays players when they are injured or off form and is expected to honour its contract, but the same cannot be said of some players. In view of his tantrums, I would like to see Arnie depart WHU as soon as possible. If he stays, we will see the same pattern repeated in the summer and in other windows and the Club will continue to be held to ransom.
  • Aslef personally I think there are many factors, but when you’ve played international football and been a decent player in the PL at the age of 29 I’m not sure you go to China to “win trophies” at 34 maybe.....

    He should already be set for life, numerous signing on fees at 10% and money for that leech of a bother. But obviously he isn’t, and that’s up to him, but try and act in a dignified manner, let’s not try and mug the club, manager and fans off eh?

    I can tell you now, this has got me way more angry than the Payet situation, and Arnie can’t match what Payet did for us.
  • edited January 2019
    Pengeman

    Nothing I have read suggests that the squad would have any problem with Arnie if he stays, and if he does the business on the pitch nor will most fans, I would imagine.

    He's the best forward we've had in years, and I would be much happier seeing hi play the rest of this season with us. We're a far more dangerous attacking unit with him on the pitch.

    I don't really get why so many fans seem to be taking it so personally. The club would axe or sell any player in a heartbeat if it suited them, and it wouldn't matter how much the player wanted to stay. Not sure why players should be any different.

    As ASLEF has pointed out, Arnie trained all week, but Pelle chose not to use him. Not sure why that paints Arnie in such a bad light. No one is having a go at Perez for not making the 18...
  • I don't remember all this hate for Vaz Te when he put in a transfer request.
  • Well we’ll see what happens when he doesn’t get his move & how he applies himself for the rest of the season...
  • edited January 2019
    MrsGrey, from wiki:

    RVT: "The statistics are evident to all but, despite this, it has been made obvious to myself and my representatives that I am not in the manager's plans. Therefore, it is with a heavy heart that I submit a transfer request and look to join a club where my approach to the game will be appreciated."

    Not exactly the same situation as Arnautovic.
  • If he’d come out and said that he’d never really had thought to leave but the money is ridiculous and he just couldn’t turn it down then I think people would have more sympathy. However his brother said that Arnie wants to win trophies and they felt this was too good an opportunity.
    Unless I’m mistaken the Chinese super league is hardly worthy of the name at the current time so why not get a move to Leyton orient who currently seem likely to win the national league and he’d get a medal.
  • Pengeman said:

    In view of his tantrums, I would like to see Arnie depart WHU as soon as possible. If he stays, we will see the same pattern repeated in the summer and in other windows and the Club will continue to be held to ransom.

    What tantrums? Being annoyed when substituted against Birmingham?
  • But obviously he isn’t, and that’s up to him, but try and act in a dignified manner, let’s not try and mug the club, manager and fans off eh?

    How has he tried to mug anyone off? He trained all week but the manager decided to leave him out of the squad.
  • edited January 2019
    Bubbles.

    I know his motives were different.

    He wanted to be 'first name on the teamsheet', rather than stay and play a back-up role (which was still nevertheless essential to our squad, providing quality cover for injuries and enabling rotation of players, esp in Cup games, that would help maximise our performance over a season). So his wishing to break his contract was still going to have a negative effect on the club.

    Also, another thing that makes it not the same situation - Vaz Te asked to move. Arnie has only responded to (as far as we know, unsolicited) outside interest.

    Is that why the difference, though ... people don't like the idea of Arnie moving to earn more money? ;hmm

  • According to Sky the club has said they won’t be bullied into selling players they don’t want to sell and his valuation is £50M and he is likely to stay. However situation may change as Chinese window closes 28 Feb.
  • edited January 2019
    Sorry, but come on. He trained all week well according to Pellegrini, who then felt he had to leave him out on Saturday. So obviously something happened on Friday which Pelle questioned & what ever that was Arnie should be made to answer for.

    This isn’t about him wanting to earn big bucks. Fair play to him for that. It’s his life. This is about him doing the right thing whilst he remains a West Ham player, which could be another 3 years.

    In the words of his spokesman:
    “Marko is professional and is preparing himself for the Arsenal game. He will give 100 per cent for West Ham. That is Marko. He will never change.

    “Until he is no longer a West Ham player, he will give everything to the club. He hopes the fans can respect his wishes.”
  • Mrs G as far as I’m aware he did ask for a move as Noble said he’d apologised to him for asking for a move.
  • edited January 2019
    thorn

    Not sure Noble said that. I thought I saw somewhere that he was sorry for wanting to go, but that could be false memory.

    What Marky Mark did say was:
    I’m not qualified to comment on transfer stuff on any player because it’s nothing to do with me, but I know he loves this club — and we love him.
    and
    I know him well and I speak to him a lot. Believe me, he loves West Ham and the fans.
  • Lukerz said:

    Sorry, but come on. He trained all week well according to Pellegrini, who then felt he had to leave him out on Saturday. So obviously something happened on Friday which Pelle questioned & what ever that was Arnie should be made to answer for.

    We don't know that anything happened on Friday, for all we know Pellegrini could have had doubts when he subbed Arnie against Arsenal but decided to let Arnie train as normal just in case.
  • thorn, he wanted the club to accept the offer/he asked the club to agree to his move... AFTER the offer came in.

    Not the same thing.

    'It is his great desire that West Ham accept the offer from China.'
  • Lukerz said:

    Sorry, but come on. He trained all week well according to Pellegrini, who then felt he had to leave him out on Saturday. So obviously something happened on Friday

    No necessarily.

    Lots of players train all week and don't make the matchday squad.
  • Maybe Pelle thought that while Arnie would be OK to play, a negative fan reaction at the ground might have a negative impact on the other players.
  • MrsGrey

    Arnie, when fit, is/was 'first name on the teamsheet' and therefore considered as more important to us than RVT who, if as you say, was being used for back-up only. The loss of Arnie will impact us more than the loss of RVT would have.

    I agree with what Thorn said:
    "If he’d come out and said that he’d never really had thought to leave but the money is ridiculous and he just couldn’t turn it down then I think people would have more sympathy."

  • edited January 2019
    I think it is the same thing. The offer didn’t come out of the blue as his brother was obviously trying to set it up and he would have known of it. I doubt the Chinese club contacted us and we said to Arnie and his brother we’ve had an offer for you and they’re offering you £200k per week.
    To me, saying to the club I want you to accept the offer construes a transfer request.
    At no point, to my knowledge did Arnie say that he’s aware of an offer but he’s a West Ham player and it’s not up to him but if the club are prepared to accept it then I’ll have to consider it.
    I may be wrong but I think the whole thing has been engineered by he and his brother, primarily the latter.
  • But obviously he isn’t, and that’s up to him, but try and act in a dignified manner, let’s not try and mug the club, manager and fans off eh?

    How has he tried to mug anyone off? He trained all week but the manager decided to leave him out of the squad.
    His brother is employed by him, therefore he owns that....

    He’s said that he will continue to give 100% but clearly in training something fell short whether it was his effort, form or his head being turned...he owns that as well

    There must’ve been other times when he may of fallen short in training but his head was where it should be and he got picked, one of the first on the sheet probably, there is no way that MP would reduce our chances in a game by not picking him for no reason, he knows we pose way more of a threat when he’s on the pitch

    I just can’t see how this doesn’t stop at Arnie. I’d love him to stay, focus release a statement, a proper one and say he’s fully committed to the club, if he doesn’t go anywhere this window. I think they’re playing games either to get a massive pay rise from us or force our hand in the similar way the Dave’s had to take less that we probably wanted for Payet.

    If he does stay he’s got a real job on his hands winning over the fans, not impossible because normally playing well and scoring pretty much trumps anything else with our lot.
Sign In or Register to comment.